Tuckahoe oferece um ambiente amigável para pedestres, com seu layout compacto e infraestrutura acessível. Muitos destinos, incluindo lojas, restaurantes e comodidades locais, estão a uma distância razoável para ir a pé, tornando conveniente realizar pequenas viagens caminhando. As calçadas são geralmente bem conservadas, e o paisagismo das ruas da cidade favorece um deslocamento seguro e confortável para pedestres. O clima moderado da região normalmente permite caminhar durante boa parte do ano, embora variações sazonais possam influenciar o nível de conforto. No geral, caminhar é uma opção prática para se locomover, especialmente para quem permanece nas áreas centrais da cidade.

Biking in Tuckahoe can be a practical option for getting around, especially for shorter distances. The village offers a mix of residential streets and access to nearby bike-friendly paths, making it possible to navigate certain areas by bicycle. However, the terrain in some parts of the region may include hills, which could be challenging for some riders. While biking infrastructure exists in the broader Westchester County area, specific local conditions such as road sharing with vehicles should be considered.

Public transit options in Tuckahoe make it relatively easy to navigate the area and connect to nearby destinations. The Metro-North Railroad provides convenient train service, linking Tuckahoe to New York City and other parts of Westchester County. Local bus routes also serve the village, offering additional accessibility for shorter trips. The infrastructure supports these transit modes well, with stations and stops located in accessible areas. Public transit can be a practical choice, especially for those looking to avoid driving, though weather conditions may occasionally impact travel.