Amityville features a pedestrian-friendly environment, particularly in its downtown area, which has been designed to promote walkability. Many amenities, shops, and services are within walking distance, making it convenient for short trips on foot. The area features sidewalks and pedestrian infrastructure that support safe and accessible walking. However, the feasibility of walking as a primary mode of transportation may depend on the specific location within Amityville, as some areas may require longer distances to reach key destinations. Seasonal weather variations, such as cold winters or hot summers, could also influence the comfort of walking.

Cycling in Amityville is supported by some infrastructure, with ongoing efforts to improve connectivity for cyclists. The town’s relatively compact layout makes it possible to reach many destinations by bike, especially in the downtown area. However, factors such as traffic patterns and the availability of dedicated bike lanes may influence the ease of biking. Riders should consider local conditions, including road safety and distances between destinations, when planning their trips.

Public transportation in Amityville includes options that can be useful for getting around the area. The Long Island Rail Road station in Amityville provides a key connection for commuters and travelers, while bus routes run along major streets like Broadway (New York State Route 110). These services make it possible to access various parts of the town and nearby areas. However, the infrastructure leans toward being auto-oriented, which may affect the convenience of public transit for some trips. Public transportation can be a practical choice depending on the specific destination and schedule.