Cutler Bay offre un mix di aree pedonabili, in particolare nei quartieri residenziali e vicino ai parchi locali, anche se camminare come mezzo di trasporto principale potrebbe avere dei limiti. Sebbene alcune aree includano marciapiedi e percorsi pedonali, la disposizione della città e le distanze tra le destinazioni chiave, come centri commerciali e strutture pubbliche, possono rendere meno pratico camminare per le commissioni quotidiane. Inoltre, il clima caldo e umido, soprattutto durante i mesi estivi, può essere un fattore da considerare. Camminare è più comodo per brevi tragitti o scopi ricreativi, soprattutto nelle zone con sentieri dedicati o percorsi ombreggiati.

Biking in Cutler Bay is supported by some bike infrastructure, including bike lanes and trails, which can make it a practical way to get around certain areas. The Old Cutler Bay Trail is a notable route that connects to nearby communities and provides a scenic option for cyclists. However, the ease of biking may depend on the specific destination, as infrastructure varies across the town. The generally flat terrain is favorable for biking, but distances between locations may influence its practicality.

Public transit options in Cutler Bay include buses and the South Dade Transitway, which connects the area to nearby cities such as Homestead and Dadeland. The transitway offers a convenient route for those traveling along major corridors. While buses are available, the spread-out nature of the area may make some destinations less accessible without additional transportation. The infrastructure supports commuting to key locations, but factors like distance and the need for transfers could influence the ease of travel. Public transit can be a practical choice for certain routes, especially for those connecting to larger transit hubs.