Carmel offers a pedestrian-friendly environment, particularly in areas like Midtown and the Arts District, where destinations such as restaurants, shops, and public spaces are within easy walking distance. The city has invested in pedestrian infrastructure, including well-maintained sidewalks, crosswalks, and trails like the Monon Greenway, which connects key parts of the community. While walking is convenient in these central areas, longer distances between neighborhoods and potential seasonal weather challenges, such as cold winters, may make walking less practical for all trips. Overall, walking is a pleasant and accessible option for exploring certain parts of Carmel.

Biking in Carmel is supported by a well-developed network of bike paths and trails, making it a practical option for getting around. The city features over 200 miles of bike-friendly infrastructure, including the popular Monon Greenway, which connects various parts of Carmel and extends to nearby areas. Many streets also include bike paths, and several trails are maintained year-round, including during snowy conditions. The relatively compact layout and accessible trails make biking a convenient way to reach local destinations, though individual preferences and distances should be considered.

As opções de transporte público em Carmélo são limitadas, pois a cidade não tem atualmente um sistema tradicional, como ônibus, VLT ou troles. A maioria dos residentes usa veículos pessoais para se deslocar pela área. Embora existam alguns serviços especializados que exigem agendamento com antecedência, eles não foram criados para o deslocamento diário em geral. O layout e a infraestrutura da cidade são mais voltados para os carros, o que pode tornar menos prática a mobilidade do transporte público.